Seminar Briefing: NHS Agency Staffing and the Impact of Recent Interventions

We have just published Seminar Briefing 22, which summarises a seminar led by Chris Mullin, Chief Economist at the Department of Health in the UK. The title of the seminar was ‘NHS Agency Staffing and the Impact of Recent Interventions’.

The NHS is one of the biggest employers in the world, with around 1.7 million staff across all NHS services. However, difficulty in predicting demand and the long lead time for training health care staff means that there can sometimes be a shortfall in available staff. This has made recruitment agencies and individual locum staff important suppliers of labour in the NHS.

Agency staff can attract high prices and be administratively expensive. Where agencies have significant market power, they may attract permanent NHS staff and put more pressure on local services. In the first six months of the 2015/16 fiscal year, year-on-year growth in agency spending reached 30% and the total bill was on track to reach £4 billion. In our Seminar Briefing, Chris explores some of the reasons for this increase in the use of agency staff.

Interventions – including ‘price caps’ – have been introduced to try to curb spending on agency staff. Speaking from his experience in designing and implementing these caps on agency rates, Chris describes the nature of these demand-side price caps and the context in which they were introduced.

The table below shows the price caps relative to equivalent NHS staff pay.

 

Junior doctors

Other clinical staff

Non-clinical staff

Nov 2015

+ 150%

+ 100%

+ 55%

Feb 2016

+ 100%

+ 75%

+ 55%

Apr 2016

+ 55%

+ 55%

+ 55%

Early indications suggest that the price caps were at least partially effective in reversing the growth in spending on agency staff, particularly for nursing staff. Data on agency nursing staff prices show a decline of about 18%. Our Seminar Briefing presents these and other key data sources that describe the impact. The experience of using price caps in the NHS may offer important lessons for other contexts in which agency staffing plays a significant role, such as in social care and education.

Read the full Seminar Briefing here.

Posted in Competition, Health Care Systems, Other Public Policy | Tagged Seminar Briefing